News and Updates

6 Jun 2019

Group Certification back in focus

Internal Control System (ICS), the right concept if supported by useful IT-tools

We are all aware of the importance of smallholder farmers. These comprise about 90% of all farms worldwide and produce a substantial proportion of the world’s food, estimated at about 70%. Large scale agriculture embedded in the current global food system will continue to fail in feeding the world’s population, least the poor. This is one of the reasons why the organic sector (IMO and Naturland and later on IFOAM) developed what is called the Internal Certification System (ICS) for Grower Groups. Another reason is that small farmers as single operation could never afford the regulatory (and private) systems’ burden of external inspection and certification, being too costly. The EU Organic as well as the USDA NOP Regulations and some other regulatory systems (e.g. India, Canada) have incorporated the ICS is its implementation.

Since about 20 years not much has happened – apart from the implementation of the ICS concept in hundreds of smallholder groups worldwide. Depending on the group and the external certification body, its quality ranged from merely paper pushing to excellent. Accreditation reports of USDA and EU Accreditation of certifiers show the deficiencies in ICS implementation and oversight. Consequently, USDA under its Sound and Sensible Initiative in 2014/ 15 assigned Organic Services and US consultant Katherine DiMatteo to analyse policies and concept of ICS. Group Integrity, a social business of Organic Services, is one answer to the weak ICS implementation. Knowing group systems since the first were certified in the 1980ies, Organic Services adapted ECERT®, Intact’s ERP certification management software for group certification. Some major certifiers took part in its adaptation. Unfortunately, despite the current still too few users, neither regulators nor certifiers or development organizations have pushed this helpful tool for the benefit of groups.

In the meantime, the EU has sparked off a discussion around ICS with incorporating group certification in its revised regulation for being applied within the EU. At the same time, the USDA NOP under its enhanced enforcement is said to have taken the issue up and higher on its agenda. During last year FIBL conducted a short survey on the state of grower group certification that was presented at BIOFACH and led to the interesting conclusion that the implementation of ICS is fairly weak, although the right concept if supported by useful IT-tools. Finally, IFOAM initiated a working group on ICS, at which Organic Services’ director and expert Mildred Steidle participates, to discuss the group certification concept and its implementation. The (first) meeting took place in May 2019. Our conclusion is that there will not be much development and or changes to the ICS concept. It is tested and has shown to produce reliable results. Implementation is where the problem lies! Group Integrity with its flexibility to be adapted to any set of standards, its multi-standards’ checklist and many other useful functionalities, e.g. the integration of product flow into Check Organic, is the answer to any group’s ICS performance. In addition, Group Integrity is affordable and saves money and time both internal and during external inspection.

In case there are any questions, never hesitate to contact us.

Latest news
27 Jul 2021

Satellite imagery + Artificial Intelligence + Mass Balancing...

Read more
9 Jul 2021

The shorter the better – this is a common conclusion when it...

Read more
6 Jul 2021
29 Jun 2021

When Mustafa Akyuz studied agronomy in the 1980s, hardly...

Read more
23 Jun 2021

Since we at Organic Services know that no group is like any...

Read more
29 Apr 2021

In our spring newsletter, we reflect on the BIOFACH eSPECIAL...

Read more
15 Apr 2021

The Corona pandemic has proved that digital tools can...

Read more
26 Mar 2021

Within the DIGICHECK project, we will develop suggestions on...

Read more
19 Mar 2021

Re-launching a website is a way of re-discovering your own...

Read more
5 Mar 2021

Usually, February is always a buzzing month for us filled...

Read more
11 Feb 2021

Find all the details on our upcoming online events during...

Read more
1 Feb 2021

Corona has turned the world upside down, but organic is...

Read more
29 Jan 2021

Watch our new video and learn more about our mission and...

Read more
21 Dec 2020

What a rough ride! For New Year’s Eve we should all have one...

Read more
20 Oct 2020

Digitalisation is a buzz word and many people don’t know...

Read more
13 Oct 2020
15 Sep 2020

We from Organic Services would like to encourage all our...

Read more

To top